• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header left navigation
  • Skip to site footer
  • Home
  • About
    • Commenting Policy
    • Banners
    • Spam Liker Hall of Shame
    • Podcast
  • Reviews
  • Guides
    • List of Suggested Manga
  • Kireina Yuri
  • Subscribe
    • RSS Feed
    • Mastodon
    • Bluesky (Bridged, Blog Feed Only)
    • Misskey
    • Feedburner
    • Anime Blog Tracker
    • Comments Feed
    • Add to Feedly
    • WordPress Reader

Chikorita157's Anime Blog

Anime blog that focuses on Yuri and School Girl Slice of Life Anime and Editorials

  • Tab 1
  • Tab 3
  • Tab 3
  • Home
  • About
    • Commenting Policy
    • Banners
    • Spam Liker Hall of Shame
    • Podcast
  • Reviews
  • Guides
    • List of Suggested Manga
  • Kireina Yuri
  • Subscribe
    • RSS Feed
    • Mastodon
    • Bluesky (Bridged, Blog Feed Only)
    • Misskey
    • Feedburner
    • Anime Blog Tracker
    • Comments Feed
    • Add to Feedly
    • WordPress Reader

comedy

moe

drama

music

opinion

final impressions

yuri

idol

action

kyoani

Bang Dream and the Girl-Band Boom, Does it Even Exist or is it a Pipe dream?

April 18, 2017 by Chikorita157 4 Comments

For a while now, I have come across an article about BanG Dream. It’s about a statement that Kidani Takaaki made.  He said that “the idol boom that has continued until now is already finished this year.”

In other words, he believes that idols will make way for the girl-band boom. However, I am very skeptical of that for many reasons that I will share.

First off, let’s talk about bands in anime, specifically girl bands. It’s a staple seen in most school anime as there is usually a club that focuses on playing music. Of course, this is usually a small aspect of the show, although enjoyable when the band performs. Some popular examples of girl bands performing is the performance of “God Knows” in Suzumiya Haruhi and Girls Dead Monster in Angel Beats. While these music performances are only a small aspect, it brings epic moments that makes their performances very memorable.

While there is anime like Beck, which focuses on bands in general, there are anime that focuses on girl bands also. K-ON, which aired back in 2009 became very popular. Sure, it focused more on slice of life rather than music, the character development and the music performances made the show every popular. Eventually, it went on to having a sequel and a movie. Also, there is Show by Rock, which has girl-bands. However, it focuses mostly on rock bands of both genders and of course, the story is crazy. Aside from also having a mobile game, it’s fairly popular.

Now let’s focus on Takaaki’s statement. He believes that the idol boom will disappear and the girl-band boom will begin. However, after taking an overall look of BanG Dream both the fandom and the show itself, I don’t necessarily agree. There are many reasons why the girl-band boom hasn’t started and probably won’t happen anytime soon. Let’s focus on a few reasons why.

First off, idols are still very popular. Sure, other idol shows like Wake Up Girls may not be popular as the big three (Aikatsu, Love Live and Idolmaster), the series take a realistic approach. Still, idols are a big part of Japan’s subculture. It mostly because idols and the culture of cuteness in Japan goes hand in hand.

While sturgeon’s law applies, of course there are going to be a lot of mediocre and crappy idol anime, manga and video games. This doesn’t mean that creators can’t create good stories or video games involving idols. Unlike girl bands, idols are already entrenched in Japanese culture and I don’t see it going away anytime soon. Unless Idolmaster, Love Live, Aikatsu, AKB48 or even Vocaloid becomes irrelevant, Takaaki’s statement doesn’t hold any water.

Second, I don’t believe there will be a band boom because BanG Dream haven’t defined the genre to deserve frontrunner status. Sure, it’s an enjoyable show, but it doesn’t have something that makes it unique and stand out compared to idol anime. It feels too much like idol genre shows, especially the first season of the original Love Live anime. As a result, I feel that this weakens the show’s position as a forerunner. This is not surprising given that the characters share similar qualities of the idols from Muse. If BanG Dream took a different approach that make the show worthy of the frontrunner status, I would think differently. Sadly, this is not the case.

Lastly, idol genre is very versatile and diverse that you can simply combine the girl band aspect into the idol genre. In other words, there isn’t a need to be a separate boom to happen since it’s mostly the same thing. Instead of dancing, they will be playing instruments while singing. With that, this makes me wonder why there needs to be a separate genre boom to accomplish this in the first place? Maybe if girls start forming rock and roll bands that focuses more on coolness instead of cuteness, I would think differently.

In short, I disagree with Takaaki’s statement. I do not think BanG Dream is the forerunner of the girl band boom nor there is a girl-band boom. It shows with very few people are talking about the show overseas (only a small handful of blogs are covering it). Moreover, there only a few participants on the doujin event. Still, I think there are many reasons this is the case ranging from the slow development to the late premiere.

To me, the main reason BanG Dream is not the forerunner is because it doesn’t bring anything new to the table to make people interested. It feels too similar to idol genre anime. Instead of the girls dancing, they play instruments instead with similar style music. That said, this doesn’t mean that the boom won’t happen in the future. Someone can create a girl-band anime or manga that might create a huge following like predecessors did.

With that, what do you think? Do you think that there is a girl-band boom? If not, feel free to share why you don’t think so.

If you see this text, this site has stolen my content. If you are affected by content thieves, look this domain up on a Whois Service, look up the IP and send a DMCA takedown with the host provider. STOP STEALING CONTENT AND MAKE YOUR OWN. Also,  MATRIXAT, go fuck yourself you fucking thief!

Share this:

  • Mastodon
  • Bluesky
  • Share on Tumblr
  • Print
  • Email

Related

What’s your response?
0 responses
Love
Love
0
Like
Like
0
Surprised
Surprised
0
Haha
Haha
0
Thinking
Thinking
0
Sad
Sad
0
Category: BanG Dream!, EditorialsTag: fandom, girl bands, idols, music, opinion

Looking to Leave Twitter or an Alternative?

We have a new Twitter-like social network based on Mastodon that caters to Anime and Japanese media fans in addition to content creators (bloggers, video creators, podcasters), who create Anime review content or anything released to Japan called Sakurajima.

Learn More
Join Now
.

This post was handcrafted by…
Chikorita157 – who has written 3,612 posts.

Author and Owner of Chikorita157’s Anime Blog and Kireina Yuri. If you want to learn more about me, see the “About chikorita157” page.

Previous Post:BanG Dream! – Episode 12 – The Moment of Truth
Next Post:Sakura Quest – Episode 3 – Yoshino Gives Her Commitment as Queen

New Here? Review the Commenting Policy before adding a comment.

Additionally, linking to your blog should only be done in the Website field, not in the comment itself, unless it contibutes to the discussion. If you are using a Wordpress.com account to comment, you can change the website URL in the Account Settings

You can comment on this blog post using your Mastodon or Misskey account on the Fediverse or your account on Bluesky.

Simply copy this post’s URL and paste it on your Mastodon server’s search field. On Misskey, click More, then lookup and paste the post’s URL Once the post comes up, reply to that post to comment.

Note: Comments must be approved first and this functionality may not work on certain servers

On Bluesky, follow @ap.brid.gy first (if you haven’t already) and then follow @chikorita157.chikorita157.com.ap.brid.gy. Simply reply to the corresponding post to comment.

If you want to follow this blog with a Mastodon or Misskey account, click the follow button below.

Reader Interactions

2 Comments… read them or add your own.

  1. Kai :
    April 20, 2017 at 9:41 am • Magical Level: 135

    To be honest, the only girl-band genre I can name is K-ON. I didn’t watch Bang Dream, or the other girl-band shows you mentioned for that matter. And yeah, I believe the idol genre in Japan is too established for it to go away anytime soon, and even if “girl-band” genre do become a thing, not too dissimilar anyway.

    Reply
    • chikorita157 :
      April 24, 2017 at 7:58 pm • Magical Level: 3346

      I do agree. Like you mentioned, the idol is already a big part of the culture, which is why it’s not going to fade out anytime soon. Still, I do agree that they are not dissimilar given how similar Bang Dream is to an idol show.

      Reply

2 Trackbacks

  1. BanG Dream! - Episode 13 (END) - The Performance to Remember - Chikorita157's Anime Blog
  2. Bang Dream's Popularity Two Years Later, Girl-Band Boom or The Raise of Mobage? - Chikorita157's Anime Blog

Leave a ReplyCancel reply

Sidebar

Categories

Archives

Current Season

  • Mayonaka Punch
  • Na Nare Hana Nare
  • Shikanoko Nokonoko Koshitantan
  • VTuber nanda ga Haishin Kiri Wasuretara Densetsu ni Natteta

Episodic Blogging Schedule

To be decided.

Anything not covered here will be covered at Kireina Yuri with short impressions.

Non-Episodic Content

  • Editorials
  • Japanese Self-Study Progress
  • Let’s Plays
  • Podcast
  • Project iM@S
  • Reviews

Follow Us

You can subscribe to this blog via WordPress Reader

Follow Chikorita157’s Anime Blog on WordPress.com

Also follow us on Mastodon for the latest blog updates and Anime/Manga/Video Games related toots

Follow @chikorita157 on Mastodon

Get a Mastodon Account

Anime Lists

AniList
MyAnimeList

Recent Posts

Ninja to Koroshiya no Futarigurashi – Episode 6 – Robotic Satoko, Powered by AI under Satoko’s Roof

Rock wa Lady no Tashinami deshite – Episode 6 – Lilisa and The Prince of Oushin

Aru Majo ga Shinu Made – Episode 6 – The “Conceited” Witch of Lapis

Slime Taoshite 300-nen Shiranai Uchi ni Level Max ni Nattemashita – Episode 5 – Shalsha, Falfa, and Sandra Goes to School and the Return of Young Azusa

mono – Episode 4 – Winetasting and the Photography Mukbang Competition

Recent Comments

  1. 四 on Ninja to Koroshiya no Futarigurashi – Episode 6 – Robotic Satoko, Powered by AI under Satoko’s RoofMay 10, 2025
  2. damian ☃️ willcox on Ninja to Koroshiya no Futarigurashi – Episode 6 – Robotic Satoko, Powered by AI under Satoko’s RoofMay 10, 2025
  3. 四 on Ninja to Koroshiya no Futarigurashi – Episode 6 – Robotic Satoko, Powered by AI under Satoko’s RoofMay 9, 2025
  4. damian ☃️ willcox on Ninja to Koroshiya no Futarigurashi – Episode 6 – Robotic Satoko, Powered by AI under Satoko’s RoofMay 9, 2025
  5. Octavia Con Amore :pink_moon_and_stars: Succubard's Library on Ninja to Koroshiya no Futarigurashi – Episode 6 – Robotic Satoko, Powered by AI under Satoko’s RoofMay 9, 2025

RSS Kireina Yuri

  • Hibi wa Sugiredo Meshi Umashi – Episode 4 – The Shy Nana May 4, 2025
  • Maebashi Witches – Episode 5 – Never Pays to Cheat May 4, 2025
  • Hibi wa Sugiredo Meshi Umashi – Episode 3 – Shion’s Money Problems and the Weekend Trip April 27, 2025
Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy

Subscribe and Follow Us For New Content

If you want to receive the latest posts in your email, you can subscribe to this blog via email or click the follow button to follow this blog dirrectly using a Mastodon or Misskey account.

To follow this blog via Wordpress Reader, click the button on the right.

Follow Chikorita157’s Anime Blog on WordPress.com
Follow Kireina Yuri on WordPress.com

Follow us on Mastodon or BlueSky for the latest blog updates and Anime/Manga/Video Games related toots

Note for Bluesky users: Follow @ap.brid.gy first before following

Follow us on Mastodon
Follow us on Bluesky
Get a Mastodon Account

© 2009–2025 James M. All rights reserved. Images are owned by their respective owners.

All text on this page is licensed under CC BY-NC 4.0. Powered by Mai Theme.

Privacy Policy

mastodonMisskey tumblrrss